The problem with most “bad guys” is they could wind up being too human. The audience might sympathize with the lowly foot soldiers of Doominess when Hero Dogood lays on the smack-down. For example, the American Revolutionary War pitted rebellious colonists [at the time, I guess they were terrorists] against a far-off imperial overseer (the Brits). Fast forward to the modern era, and here we have the UK as USA’s supporter (sometimes the only one). In the film Rambo III (MacDonald, 1988), the lead character was fighting Soviet Russians with the help of (what would become) the Taliban. Now, I realize these examples have their basis in reality (ish), but that foundation is real enough and getting audience to suspend their collective sense of belief is getting harder and harder. What’s a gal to do?
So,
every good guy needs to fight the undead?

When
Star Wars first came out [I guess it’s
now called ‘Star Wars: Episode IV:
A New Hope…blah blah blah], audiences didn’t know what to make of
Stormtroopers. While we find out later
what the Stormtroopers are, before Lucas vomited all over my childhood made
the prequels, no one had a clue what to make of these incognizant white-clad
soldiers. Where they robots? Clones?
The reanimated corpses of former QVC hosts? Audiences did, however, understand that they
were a faceless enemy that didn’t make them think any less of Luke when he shot
them.
Although
they don’t really fit the definition of the autonomous killy-mah-jig, Nazis
deserve special mention. No one feels bad about killing Nazis. It’s why they’re in a video game every year. Seriously, you can take the world’s cutest puppy;
put a little swastika on its tiny fury arm and, all of the sudden you go from, “Awwh,
how cute!” to “DIE YOU BASTAGE!” It’s where the last Indiana Jones film went awry: no Nazi killing?!? WTF?!?
At least Tarantino got it right. Along this vein is the ever-popular Nazi
Zombie.
What
more needs to be said??
Along with the souls killing machine. It's also ok for the do good hero to kill when he is in immediate mortal danger. The hero simply can't shoot first (just ask Mr Lucas). No mater how many times the bad guy has shot or tortured our hero if the bad guy isn't pointing a gun at our noble hero and is half way through pulling the trigger the Hero can't shoot him.
ReplyDeleteLook at final scene of Lethal Weapon. Riggs beats the bad guy in a fist fight and starts to walk away because even anti-hero Riggs isn't allowed to kill him. Bad guy gets a gun and is about to shoot, This allows both anti-hero Riggs and Boyscout Murtaugh to kill him.
Terminators work especially well since it taps into the distrust of machines and the fear of being replaced by something superior. Zombies are not generally superior to Humans but Asimovs robots are. That's why all friendly robots have some restriction in them wouldn't trust robots with actual free will to not turn on us.
ReplyDeleteAsimov has the three laws.
Data from STNG just wants to be a real boy and is portrayed somewhat child like because of it.
The Star Wars droids are used mostly for comic relief and treated solely like property making it clear they are not to be considered fully sentient.
In our fiction as soon as robots loose what ever is restraining them, they seek to overthrow humanity. (Exhibit 1 the Cylons)